What drives the gap
- Material cost per square
- Labor — fiber cement is heavier and slower
- Paint or factory finish systems
- Trim and detail complexity
Where vinyl wins
Lower first cost, no paint schedule, and solid performance when wrap and flash are done right.
Best for many New Hampshire colonials and ranches when budget leads.
Where fiber cement wins
Painted look, impact feel, and longevity when maintained. HOA or design goals often push this path.
We quote both with the same wrap and flash standard so you compare systems, not shortcuts.